Pie by the Pound
HomeMenuReviewsAboutOrder now

Pie by the Pound Menu

Matzoh Pizza Available Throughout Passover


SEE BELOW

$0.00

Beverages


Purity Organic Super Juice

$5.50

Poland Spring Water

$1.75

Canned Soda

$1.95

Boylan's Soda

$2.95

Honest Tea

$2.95

Harmless Harvest Coconut Water

$5.00

Harmless Harvest Coconut Water

$4.00

Salads


House Salad

Tomato, white onion, bell peppers, romaine, oil and vinegar. Gluten free. Vegan.

$8.95 +

Arugula Parmesan Salad

Arugula, Parmesan, organic extra virgin olive, lemon oil. Gluten free.

$9.50 +

Seasonal Salad

Arugula, tomatoes, feta, red onion, bell peppers, capers and lemon dressing. Gluten free.

$9.95 +

Caprese Salad

Fresh cubed mozzarella, tomato, basil, romaine, oil and vinegar. Gluten free.

$9.95 +

Greek Salad

Feta, black olives, radicchio, tomato, red onion, romaine, oil and vinegar. Gluten free.

$9.95 +

Grilled Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken, tomato, romaine, radicchio and white onion, oil and vinegar. Gluten free.

$9.95 +

Chef Salad

Genoa salami, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, tomato, arugula, white onion, oil and vinegar. Gluten free.

$9.95 +

Truffle Grilled Sandwiches


Goat Cheese Sandwich

Goat cheese, portabella mushroom, tomato, red onion and truffle oil.

$9.95 +

5 Cheese Sandwich

Mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, provolone, Parmesan, Gorgonzola, tomato and truffle oil.

$9.95 +

Ham and Provolone Sandwich

Fresh mozzarella, ham, provolone, tomato, basil and truffle oil.

$9.95 +

Chicken Provolone Sandwich

Chicken, provolone, and truffle oil.

$9.95 +

Gluten Free Truffle Grilled Sandwiches


Gluten Free Goat Cheese Sandwich

Goat cheese, portabella mushroom, tomato, red onion and truffle oil.

$9.25 +

Gluten Free 5 Cheese Sandwich

Mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, provolone, Parmesan, Gorgonzola, tomato and truffle oil.

$9.25 +

Gluten Ham and Provolone Sandwich

Fresh mozzarella, ham, provolone, tomato, basil and truffle oil.

$9.25 +

Gluten Free Chicken Provolone Sandwich

Chicken, provolone and truffle oil.

$9.25 +

Regular Cheese Pie


Cheese Pie

Mozzarella and tomato sauce.

$14.95 +

Fresh Mozzarella Pie

Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce and basil.

$16.50 +

Fresh Cubed Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh cubed mozzarella, cubed tomato, fresh garlic, basil, oregano and arugula.

$16.95 +

Saucy Fresh Mozzarella Pie

Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh garlic, oregano and basil.

$16.25 +

Caprese Pie

Fresh mozzarella, sliced tomato, oregano and basil.

$16.50 +

Snow White Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, oregano and fresh garlic.

$16.50 +

5 Cheese Pie

Mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, provolone, Gorgonzola and Parmesan.

$16.95 +

Red Eye Pie

Fresh mozzarella, extra marinara dollops, Parmesan, basil.

$16.50 +

Gluten Free Cheese Pie


Gluten Free Cheese Pie

Mozzarella and tomato sauce. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$15.95 +

Gluten Free Fresh Mozzarella Pie

Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce and basil. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75 +

Gluten Free Fresh Cubed Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh cubed mozzarella, cubed tomato, fresh garlic, basil, oregano, arugula. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$18.50 +

Gluten Free Saucy Fresh Mozzarella Pie

Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh garlic, oregano and basil. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75 +

Gluten Free Caprese Pie

Fresh mozzarella, sliced tomato, oregano and basil. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75 +

Gluten Free Snow White Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, oregano and fresh garlic. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75 +

Gluten Free 5 Cheese Pie

Mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, provolone, Gorgonzola and Parmesan. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.50 +

Gluten Free Red Eye Pie

Fresh mozzarella, extra marinara dollops, Parmesan, basil. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75 +

Veggie Pie


Eggplant Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, grilled eggplant, Parmesan and arugula.

$16.50 +

Zucchini Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, zucchini, red onion and arugula.

$16.50 +

3 Pepper Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, red yellow and green pepper and arugula.

$16.50 +

Mushroom Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, portobello mushroom and arugula.

$16.50 +

Potato Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, walnut, rosemary, potato.

$16.50 +

Garden Pie

Mozzarella, bell peppers, sliced tomato, zucchini, lemon, arugula.

$16.50 +

Greek Salad Pie

Feta tomato sauce, red onion, olive, lettuce, tomato, radicchio.

$16.50 +

Spinach Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, spinach and garlic.

$16.50 +

Gluten Free Veggie Pie


Gluten Free Eggplant Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, grilled eggplant, Parmesan and arugula. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75

Gluten Free Zucchini Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, zucchini, red onion and arugula. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75

Gluten Free 3 Pepper Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, red yellow and green pepper, arugula. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75

Gluten Free Mushroom Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, portobello mushroom and arugula. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75

Gluten Free Potato Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, walnut, rosemary and potato. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$16.75

Gluten Free Garden Pie

Mozzarella, bell peppers, sliced tomato, zucchini, lemon, arugula. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75

Gluten Free Greek Salad Pie

Feta, tomato sauce, red onion, olive, lettuce, tomato, radicchio. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75

Gluten Free Spinach Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, spinach and garlic. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75

10.5" Gluten-Free Potato Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, walnut, rosemary and potato. Vegetarian.

$16.50

Meat Pie


Chicken Pie

Mozzarella, chicken, tomato sauce, rosemary, cubed tomato and arugula.

$17.50 +

Genoa Salami Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, Genoa salami, tomato sauce and arugula.

$17.50 +

Ham and Pepperoni Pie

Mozzarella, Italian ham, pepperoni and tomato sauce.

$17.50 +

Sausage Pie

Mozzarella, sweet Italian sausage, onions, tomato sauce and arugula.

$17.50 +

Pepperoni Pie

Mozzarella, pepperoni and tomato sauce.

$16.75 +

Prosciutto Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, prosciutto, tomato sauce and arugula.

$17.50 +

Bacon Pie

Mozzarella, bacon, tomato sauce and scallion.

$17.50 +

Brunch Pie

Mozzarella, American cheese, bacon, egg and scallion.

$15.95 +

Brunch Pie

Mozzarella, American cheese, bacon, egg, scallion.

$17.50 +

Gluten Free Meat Pie


Gluten Free Chicken Pie

Mozzarella, chicken, tomato sauce, rosemary, cubed tomato and arugula. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$18.50

Gluten Free Genoa Salami Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, Genoa salami, tomato sauce and arugula. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$18.50

Gluten Free Ham and Pepperoni Pie

Mozzarella, Italian ham, pepperoni and tomato sauce. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$18.50

Gluten Free Sausage Pie

Mozzarella, sweet Italian sausage, onions, tomato sauce and arugula. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$18.50

Gluten Free Pepperoni Pie

Mozzarella, pepperoni and tomato sauce. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.50

Gluten Free Prosciutto Pizza

Mozzarella, ricotta, prosciutto, tomato sauce and arugula. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$18.50

Gluten Free Bacon Pie

Mozzarella, bacon, tomato sauce and scallion. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$18.50

Gluten Free Brunch Pie

Mozzarella, American cheese, bacon, egg and scallion.

$17.50

Vegan Pie


Marinara Pie

Capers, fresh garlic, tomato sauce, oregano and basil.

$13.50 +

Veggie Marinara Pie

Mixed vegetables, tomato sauce, fresh garlic, capers, oregano, basil.

$16.50 +

Olive and Onion Pie

Black olives, Spanish onion, fresh garlic, tomato sauce, oregano, basil.

$14.95 +

Mushroom and Eggplant Pie

Fresh garlic, portobello mushroom, eggplant, tomato sauce, oregano and arugula.

$15.95 +

Gluten Free Dairy Free Pie


Gluten Free Marinara Pie

Capers, fresh garlic, tomato sauce, oregano and basil. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$14.95 +

Gluten Free Veggie Marinara Pie

Mixed vegetables, tomato sauce, fresh garlic, capers, oregano, basil. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.75 +

Gluten Free Olive and Onion Pie

Black olives, Spanish onion, fresh garlic, tomato sauce, oregano, basil. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$16.75 +

Gluten Free Mushroom and Eggplant Pie

Fresh garlic, portobello mushroom, eggplant, tomato sauce, oregano, arugula. Serves 1 to 2 people.

$17.25 +

Passover Cheese Pie


*Please note that featured menu items are solely considered Passover-inspired, and may not be certified kosher or kosher for Passover. Passover dietary rules are followed at restaurants' discretion.

$0.00

Matzoh Cheese Pie

Mozzarella and tomato sauce. Served on matzo crust.

$14.95 +

Matzoh Fresh Cubed Pie

Cubed fresh mozzarella, mozzarella, tomato sauce, cubed tomato, fresh garlic, oregano, basil, and arugula. Served on matzo crust.

$14.95 +

Matzoh Caprese Pie

Fresh mozzarella, sliced tomato, oregano and basil. Served on matzo crust.

$14.95 +

Matzoh 5 Cheese Pie

Mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, provolone, Gorgonzola and Parmesan. Served on matzo crust.

$14.95 +

Matzoh Fresh Mozzarella Pie

Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce and basil. Served on matzo crust.

$14.95 +

Matzoh Saucy Fresh Mozzarella Pie

Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh garlic, oregano and basil. Served on matzo crust.

$14.95 +

Matzoh Snow White Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, oregano and fresh garlic. Served on matzo crust.

$14.95 +

Matzoh Red Eye Pie

Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce dollops on top, tomato sauce, Parmesan and basil. Served on matzo crust.

$14.95 +

Passover Veggie Pie


*Please note that featured menu items are solely considered Passover-inspired, and may not be certified kosher or kosher for Passover. Passover dietary rules are followed at restaurants' discretion.

$0.00

Matzoh Eggplant Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, grilled eggplant, Parmesan and arugula. Served on matzo crust.

$16.50 +

Matzoh 3 Pepper Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, red, yellow and green pepper and arugula. Served on matzo crust.

$16.50 +

Matzoh Greek Salad Pie

Feta cheese, red onion, olive, lettuce, tomato, raddichio and tomato sauce. Served on matzo crust.

$16.50 +

Matzoh Zucchini Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, zucchini, red onion and arugula. Served on matzo crust.

$16.50 +

Matzoh Mushroom Pie

Mozzarella, tomato sauce, portobello mushroom and arugula. Served on matzo crust.

$16.50 +

Matzoh Garden Pie

Mozzarella, zucchini, red onion, sliced tomato, peppers and lemon. Served on matzo crust.

$16.50 +

Matzoh Spinach Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, spinach and fresh garlic. Served on matzo crust.

$16.50 +

Passover Meat Pie


*Please note that featured menu items are solely considered Passover-inspired, and may not be certified kosher or kosher for Passover. Passover dietary rules are followed at restaurants' discretion.

$0.00

Matzoh Chicken Pie

Mozzarella, chicken, tomato sauce, rosemary, diced tomato and arugula. Served on matzo crust.

$17.50 +

Matzoh Ham and Pepperoni Pie

Mozzarella, Italian ham, pepperoni and tomato sauce. Served on matzo crust.

$17.50 +

Matzoh Pepperoni Pie

Mozzarella, pepperoni and tomato sauce. Served on matzo crust.

$17.50 +

Matzoh Genoa Salami Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, Genoa salami, tomato sauce and arugula. Served on matzo crust.

$17.50 +

Matzoh Sausage Pie

Mozzarella, sweet Italian sausage, onions, tomato sauce and arugula. Served on matzo crust.

$17.50 +

Matzoh Bacon Pie

Mozzarella, bacon, tomato sauce and scallion. Served on matzo crust.

$17.50 +

Matzoh Prosciutto Pie

Mozzarella, ricotta, prosciutto, tomato sauce and arugula. Served on matzo crust.

$17.50 +

Passover Vegan Pie


Matzoh Marinara Pie

Capers, fresh garlic, tomato sauce, oregano and basil. Served on matzo crust.

$13.50 +

Matzoh Veggie Marinara Pie

Mixed vegetables, tomato sauce, fresh garlic, capers, oregano, basil. Served on matzo crust.

$16.50 +

Matzoh Olive and Onion Pie

Black olives, Spanish onion, fresh garlic, tomato sauce, oregano, basil. Served on matzo crust.

$14.95 +

Matzoh Mushroom and Eggplant Pie

Fresh garlic, portobello mushroom, eggplant, tomato sauce, oregano and arugula. Served on matzo crust.

$15.95 +

Desserts


Nutella Pie

Mascarpone, nutella, strawberry and banana.

$16.50 +

Apple Pie

Apple, cinnamon, and powdered sugar. Vegan.

$16.50 +

Gluten Free Apple Pie

$16.25

Large Cookie

$3.75

Gluten-Free Oatmeal Rasin Cookie

$3.75

Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie

$3.95

Gluten Free Brownie

$3.95

Gluten-Free Cranberry Orange Oatmeal Bar

$3.75

Pie by the Pound

A leading New York restaurant on Grubhub

124 4th Ave, New York, NY 10003
(212) 475-4977
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.Terms of usePrivacy policyCA privacy noticeDo not sell my info